I guess here's my point. Keep in mind, I don't know the person this topic is about, I have no stake in the game, and my comments are not directed at this service, they are 'forum' comments. All in the effort to make the forum a better place for all who use it to try to better ourselves.
Look, if someone posted they sell a service, whether it is 'cheap' or not, and they posted results showing they made like 60+% per month, what would be the first thing that would happen in here? Bingo, where are your statements. No statements, take a hike. No matter what you did with the system yourself, no matter how good the calls the person made in their room, no statements, no dice. That's not me talking, that's the forum consensus. In fact, I used to argue against statements in this forum until the pressure was so great I finally came over to their side.
Now, as we all know, what happens in sim mode when the average winners or losers are say about a point? The 'slippage' and fills become critical, and many systems that look awesome in sim are useless in the real world. In a case like this anything that isn't done with real money, as far as results, are not only of no practical use, but can be way, way off the mark, or so it has been pointed out time and again in this forum. So, here we have posted results that are what, real trading or sim? If sim, there is zero reason they should be posted. If real, then statements should be posted, not a summary of the results.
Imagine any other thread in here posting actual trading results, just not via statements. It would get shredded. And I'm not picking on Phant here, I consider Phant our best watchdog here and all-around good guy, but he's the one posting the non-statement results. And we all know, admit it Phant, if someone else posted that, for a service that charges (albeit very little), you would rip them a new one so fast our heads would spin. I'm just saying, when I see over 60+% per month claims and no statements, I keep saying to myself 'Phant will be along any time soon, or Monkey, and rip this sucker a new one.' And then I scrolled back and saw Phant posted that!
I think we should be more consistent in here, that's all. I'd like to see some actual trading statements any time I see 60+% per month results that require precise fills. Can we get them here? If not, I'm not sure this thread is of any use to anyone.