Originally posted by jatharp12
jim, You seem a little touchy on this subject, just wondering why? I've been in trish's room and she seems to do everything legit. For example, she will say that if you are on SIM, you need to touch the number above yours in order to get an accurate result. She's not trying to impress anyone with bogus results. You seem to stress how people use "shady" results because they are in SIM, but I noticed on your website you stress that you will not say if you are in SIM or not. I dont want to sound negative, because your imput on this board (though i've never posted) has been a great help to me. Just wondering if you had alterior motives for being so openly skeptical?
jatharp12,
Am I the jim you are addressing? If so, I'm completely confused. I'm not 'touchy' at all. I'm not sure where you got the idea I said 'people use "shady" results because they are in SIM'??? Can you tell me where you got that? Which post? I have mentioned, at times, the limitations of sim, especially when trading for very small profits, but overall I am a big proponent of sim, as outlined in the article on my website on sim. As far as what I say on my website:
a) I am not posting any results of any kind, ever, on my website, so it is a moot and useless point on sim or not, because there are no results anywhere on the site to discuss. It is an irrelevant point there.
b) If you read the Disclaimers page you'd see I make it very clear anyway.
The website is strictly educational, with zero claims, and no live trading services of any kind whatsoever.
But this has nothing to do with the points I was trying to make, which, apparently, have been missed entirely. Let me spell them out, again, for everyone, in as plain of English as I can.
We have all worked tirelessly in this forum to stop people from making any unsubstantiated claims. Phant (and Monkey Meat) have been leaders in calling people on the line. Post all the results you want, but if you post results, they must be accompanied by statements. Period. End of story. Otherwise it is a completely unsubstantiated claim, and serves no purpose here. This is not my 'rule', this is the consensus of this forum. When I first arrived here, I fought against this. Finally, over time, I came over to the other side, after seeing not only the endless unsubstantiated claims, but the uselessness of unsubstantiated cliams in a forum like this.
So, when Phant posted what are claims for this service, he did so in an unsubstantiated manner. This vendor can send out anything she wants, that's her business and her prerogitave. But she can't post them here without statements, or everyone is going to make an issue of it. That's the unwritten rule of this board. Phant has been a leader of this movement. To an extent, it was his posting that finally pushed me over to that side. So, when he goes ahead and posts unsubstantiated results, it creates a mess. Just because someone has a high reputation or even is a moderator in here, doesn't mean they should have special rules for them. This forum is not enhanced when unsubstantiated claims are presented. When someone like Phant starts a thread for a vendor, and then posts unsubstantiated results, we have an issue here. One of our own, our strongest defender, has broken the rules.
That's why I mentioned he would be the first to jump all over this and shred the person to ribbons if anyone but he himself had done this exact same thing. I was trying to be tactful and not be antagonistic directly to him so as to keep on friendly terms with everyone in here. I make that my policy. I was hoping to get my point across without putting anyone directly on the spot, or creating any confrontation. You've, unfortunately, forced my hand here in order to adequately answer your questions. If the posted results had been 'moderate' I would have let this slide. But we are seeing results that are fantastical, in my opinion. 60%+ per month consistently? Anyone who makes a claim like that absolutely must provide statements, or those claims should be removed from this forum. So, to have our staunchest defender against unsubstantiated claims post fantastical unsubstantiated claims, it should be discussed.
Hey, I don't want to start up any trouble here, I don't want Phant to go off on me and tell me he was just posting those for information because she sent them out, that's all. And as I made perfectly clear in one of my posts: "Keep in mind, I don't know the person this topic is about, I have no stake in the game, and my comments are not directed at this service, they are 'forum' comments." And, I guess I disagree that because this person is only charging $100 all the usual 'rules' shouldn't apply. Many, many of the most bogus vendors I have seen charge $99 for their 'course' or e-book. And some sell thousands of them, and that's not a small amount of money, it's only small per person.
Look, if everyone in here thinks 60% per month is a reasonable consistent rate of return for traders, and that those with a good reputation should be able to post unsubstantiated claims for services, if they are cheap, for that level of performance, I'll just go back to my cave and leave you all to post away. Yes, I know hedge fund trading and trading three mini's are not the same thing, and I know the best traders in here claim that they make way more than 60% a month (notice, though, not one single statement has been produced to substantiate that...), but I think anyone is doing a grave diservice to new traders if they imply that over 700% consistent returns per year is 'doable' for most traders. That's why I try to get people back to earth with more reasonable return expectations.
Yes, Tiger Woods can really hit a golf ball, and MJ was something with air time, but I am not of that otherworldly level. And I don't think most new traders are, either. But they are led to believe, and to some extent in this forum, that if you can 'only make' 700% a year, year after year, you must really suck. And every time I see that, unsubstantiated, I am going to rail against it, or just leave and let those that want the forum to go in that direction have their way. But I am never going to tell new traders that they have a reasonably good chance to make those kinds of returns. If we let this thread stand as is, we have done just that, in my opinion.
Now, go ahead, rip me up if you want, but if I can't speak my mind, I'm of no use to this forum. You get the real me, all of it, or none. Guy gave us all the power to vote a post up or down, let's see what people do with what I've said here. Vote on this post. Tell me if you want me to post what I think, or go away.